High Performance Health Podcast
Perimenopause and Muscle Quality: Why Your Muscle Can Change Even If Your Weight Doesn't | Dr. Abbie Smith-Ryan
In this episode of High Performance Health, Angela Foster speaks with exercise scientist Dr. Abbie Smith-Ryan about the overlooked importance of muscle quality, and why it matters for metabolic health, insulin sensitivity and longevity.
AUDIO
TRANSCRIPT
(Transcribed by TurboScribe. Go Unlimited to remove this message.)
[Angela Foster] (0:00 - 0:19)
Let's kick off with muscle and specifically muscle quality. So your research suggests that one of the earliest changes through that perimenopause transition may not be in relation to losing muscle but also in relation to losing muscle quality. I don't think many women are thinking about this.
Can you explain more about that?
[Dr. Abbie Smith-Ryan] (0:19 - 1:49)
Absolutely. And so what we know for both men and women as we age, there is an increased likelihood to lose muscle size. But some of our early work identified that there's also a change in muscle quality.
And the way I like to describe that is when we're younger, our muscle might look more like a fillet, a steak that's very lean. And as we age, particularly through perimenopause, it can take on more characteristics of, let's say, a rib eye, more fatty infiltration, more connective infiltration within the muscle. And why that's important, well, one, I don't think a lot of people talk about it because it's very difficult to measure.
Typically, we're measuring it via an MRI or a PQCT or an ultrasound. You can't look at a muscle and know if the muscle quality is changing. However, that change in muscle quality is also often reflective in metabolic parameters.
Sometimes that's blood work. Sometimes it's some other things. But that's often why people aren't talking about it.
And when we have a lot of high performers like your audience, that even if we maintain our training or maybe it's an insufficient stimulus, a lot of times that muscle quality can still change with ageing. Some of it's normal ageing. And then we have seen that potentially in that perimenopause, so that early 40s into 50s that there might be a slightly bigger increase in or loss of muscle quality increase in connective tissue and fatty infiltration.
[Angela Foster] (1:50 - 1:55)
And so if we're getting more fatty infiltration into the muscle, will that affect our metabolic health?
[Dr. Abbie Smith-Ryan] (1:56 - 3:29)
Yes, absolutely. So if we think about muscle, it's an organ of longevity, partly because it uptakes and utilises glucose and helps with insulin sensitivity. And so if we have more of that fatty infiltration and connective tissue, so we have less active muscle tissue, less tissue that can uptake the insulin, the glucose, and even activate what we call GLUT4, being able to use glucose, it can impact our metabolic health.
I will say, and I'll have to send some papers to link, we see these classic examples of old versus young muscle or untrained versus trained. And what I like to remind a lot of women, it's not dramatic. If you are training, you are still doing things to help with muscle quality, but it's part of that conversation as we might want to start changing the stimulus or even some of the neurological aspects of, let's say, power training that can help our muscle quality be maintained through that timeframe.
And what I mean by that is as we age, we do tend to have, regardless if we're male or female, we have muscle fibres that become less like type two muscle fibres and more like type one with natural ageing. And so from a physiology perspective, if we can continue to stimulate those muscle fibres and motor units with those higher load, higher intensity, higher power, we can theoretically help maintain that quality of the muscle longer.
[Angela Foster] (3:29 - 4:04)
Very interesting. So I want to kind of circle back to that. You were saying that you wouldn't necessarily be able to tell by looking at it.
So if a woman's looking at her body composition, like I certainly noticed, right, a 50 is harder, isn't it? To keep, to hold onto and to gain muscle, especially if you're stressed or you're not sleeping particularly well, would you see less definition yourself in the mirror? Like, would you find that you're kind of getting, a common complaint I hear from my audience is that in addition to belly fat is I feel like I'm getting softer, right?
I'm not seeing the same results from my training. Could that be down to intramuscular fat?
[Dr. Abbie Smith-Ryan] (4:04 - 4:53)
Theoretically, no, you can't tell by looking at one thing we have seen most recently is we might see and do an intervention that's hypertrophic meant to increase lean mass. And if we're using a tool, let's say like a Dexa, it's maybe not detecting that change and increase in lean mass because it's actually improving muscle quality, which the Dexa can't measure. And so it tells me as a researcher, one, we need more tools and we're having conversations with new technology aspects of how can we measure this in a more feasible way?
Currently, you can't tell by looking and you can't tell by like a mainstream Dexa or an in-body. It has to be more of an imaging technique. And even with that imaging, most sites are not set up to measure quality.
[Angela Foster] (4:54 - 5:08)
So when we're looking at the inputs, then you mentioned power-based training. If we're looking at the things that affect muscle quality, I suppose, if we start to understand those, then we can adapt our training to get the best quality of muscle possible. What would those be?
[Dr. Abbie Smith-Ryan] (5:08 - 6:37)
So I'll answer the training question. I think nutrition is also a really important conversation within that. And so when we look at training, another example I like to give, and we think about the elements of training is if we think about an obese muscle, they have more muscle than someone that's lean, but the muscle itself has lower quality.
And so it's not always about the amount of muscle, it is about the quality. And so when we think about training, if we are doing only aerobic exercise or we're continuing to provide the same stimulus over time, it's still great. Like a lot of times the goal doesn't have to be muscle building, but we want to think about how do we continue to recruit those type two motor units and those type two muscle fibres as we age.
And typically we need to do some higher load or that power-based training. And that can look a lot of different ways. It looks very different from a woman that's doing that now and adding in a day here or there, or it looks different from someone that's completely sedentary and just started to train.
So it doesn't always have to be this massively heavy load or lots of plyometrics, but for the high performer, we need to start thinking about what's that added stimulus to be able to recruit those larger motor units, which can help stimulate those characteristics and help maintain muscle quality.
[Angela Foster] (6:37 - 6:49)
Interesting. And it's that type of training, when you start sort of elevating in that way, also helps, right? With overall metabolic health and fat loss quite commonly as well, and also pulling visceral fat.
So you kind of, many benefits.
[Dr. Abbie Smith-Ryan] (6:50 - 8:27)
A hundred percent. And as I, like one of my key areas of research is using high intensity interval training. And part of why we do that, especially in a lab-based scenario, is that we have shown, first of all, it does allow for increased muscle size and it increases muscle quality and metabolic health very rapidly.
And so because of not only that requirement of recruiting type two motor units, but also that metabolic demand. And it's really important. I think this speaks to when we think about metabolism with high intensity training during training, if it's high intensity, you're actually relying on a lot of carbohydrate, which is a good thing.
We're using carbohydrate, we're requiring the mitochondria to be really active. That's very prevalent in high intensity interval training. And then post exercise, specifically high intensity exercise, what we see is what we call excess post-oxygen consumption.
And really what we see there is this decrease in carbohydrate refuelling and increase in fat utilisation to help replenish what was lost in training. And that metabolic demand extends longer than let's say, you know, a long walk or an endurance bout. And so there's more metabolic happenings post-exercise too.
And that really helps us shift from carbohydrate to fat in different stages and the demand that's at need, which does help us with our insulin use, our glucose use, and our fat use.
(Transcribed by TurboScribe. Go Unlimited to remove this message.)
DESCRIPTION
Discover how fatty infiltration and connective tissue can change the composition of your muscles, why muscle size doesn't tell the whole story, and how resistance training, power-based exercise and high-intensity interval training (HIIT) may help preserve muscle quality as you age.
- Muscle Quality vs. Muscle Size: Why the composition of your muscle matters just as much as how much you have.
- Perimenopause and Muscle Changes: How fatty infiltration and connective tissue may increase during the menopause transition.
- Muscle and Metabolic Health: Why muscle quality influences glucose utilisation and insulin sensitivity.
- What Your DEXA Scan Misses: Why standard body composition scans cannot detect improvements in muscle quality.
- The Importance of Type II Muscle Fibres: How higher-load and power-based training may help preserve muscle function.
Why Your Training Needs to Evolve: How changing your exercise stimulus can help recruit larger motor units.
HIIT for Muscle Quality and Metabolism: How high-intensity inter
VIDEO
VALUABLE RESOURCES
Click here for discounts on all the products I personally use and recommend
The Ultimate Guide to Creatine for Women -
👉 https://academy.angelafosterperformance.com/creatine-guide
VALUABLE RESOURCES
- Take the BioSyncing Quiz to help you understand what’s actually happening in your body — and how to fix it.
👉 https://biosyncing.scoreapp.com/
Want to go deeper? Start here:
Reset your hormones, restore your energy, and reconnect with your body in just 21 days.
👉 https://www.highperformance-health.com
Disclaimer: The High Performance Health Podcast is for general information purposes only and do not constitute the practice of professional or coaching advice and no client relationship is formed. The use of information on this podcast, or materials linked from this podcast is at the user's own risk. The content of this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for medical or other professional advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Users should seek the assistance of their medical doctor or other health care professional for before taking any steps to implement any of the items discussed in this podcast.
Recent Episodes
About Angela
Angela Foster is an award winning Nutritionist, Health & Performance Coach, Keynote Speaker and Host of The High Performance Health Podcast.
A former corporate lawyer turned industry leader in biohacking and health optimisation for women, Angela regularly gives keynotes to large fitness, health and wellness events including the Health Optimisation summit, The Biohacker summit, Dragonfly live, Elevate Fitness conference and Gaia TV. She also delivers Health Optimisation and Performance Workshops to large multinational corporations and senior leaders with a strong focus on women’s health and burnout prevention.
Angela is also the creator of BioSyncing® a blueprint for high performing women who want to ditch burnout, harmonise their hormones and elevate their life.





