High Performance Health Podcast
The Creatine Mistake Almost Every Woman Over 40 Makes | Angela Foster
In this video, I explain the three mistakes that stop women over 40 getting the benefits of creatine, from taking a dose designed for young men to quitting before your muscles have had time to fill up.
AUDIO
TRANSCRIPT
[Angela]
I ignored creatine for years because I thought it was for men who wanted to get big. That was a mistake because for women over 40, when muscle gets harder to hold on to every single year, it might be the highest returning supplement you're not taking. It costs about the price of a coffee a week.
It's not a fat burner and it won't do the work for you, but it can help you to hold on to muscle and strength even in the weeks your training falls apart. And most women who take it are getting it wrong. So today I'm going to show you the three mistakes that stop women getting the benefit, exactly how much to take for your goal and the one thing it does for your sleep that I didn't expect.
I'm Angela Foster, a former corporate lawyer turned high performance health coach, and I've helped hundreds of women optimise their health, body composition, and longevity. The first mistake I see is you're taking a dose that was designed for someone else. There is more research on creatine than almost anything else in sports science, around a thousand or more studies, and almost all of the advice you heard about it was designed for young men.
Research reviews report that women have 70 to 80 percent lower total creatine stores than men, mostly because we carry less muscle. And what many women don't realise is that your creatine stores shift across your menstrual cycle. Oestrogen influences how much your body makes, stores, and uses creatine, so your levels aren't a flat line across the month.
After menopause, when oestrogen drops, that support drops too, which is one more reason creatine stops being an option in your 40s and 50s. So if you tried creatine years ago and felt nothing, you may have been taking a dose designed for a different body or stage of life when your stores were higher than they are now. Here's a really simple way to think about the dose.
Your muscles have a limited amount of creatine they can store. Once they're full, they're full. Below that, you're leaving benefits on the table.
For most women, five grammes a day is the place to start. That helps support muscle and recovery, but the right dose depends on your goal. Some of the research I'm about to show you used more, up to 10 or 12 grammes a day, and I'll give you the full breakdown by goal at the end.
Now, consistency matters far more than loading, so you want to pick a dose that you can take every day, including on your rest days. Let me first show you the study that made me change my own approach. This was a 12-week trial, and it looked at adults in midlife, not college athletes or bodybuilders, but people our age.
They took 10 grammes of creatine a day, split into two doses, and they did no extra exercise at all. No new gym programme, no added cardio or anything else. By the end of 12 weeks, they had gained lean muscle, and when tested, they could lift more weight with both their upper and their lower body.
Their bench press and leg press were measurably stronger from a supplement, but with no change to their training. In the same study, people who took creatine alongside an exercise and weight loss programme did even better. More fat loss, bigger strength gains, more muscular endurance.
So this is not a reason to skip the gym. If you're training, creatine can help your training go further and your recovery faster, but on the weeks where life gets in the way, and you know the weeks I mean, the evidence suggests it can still be doing something for you in the background. That's the difference between a supplement that only works when you're perfect and one that works when you're human.
If you're in peri or postmenopausal and you feel like your body's responding to training the way it used to, I would love to hear about it. Comment below and tell me what changed for you and whether you tried creatine at that point. Mistake number two, you're blaming it for bloating.
This is the one that stops most women before they start. You've heard that it makes you bloated or holds water or makes you look puffy, but here's what's actually happening. Creatine pulls water into the muscle cell.
That's part of how it works. It's not water under your skin making you look puffy, it's water inside the making it look fuller and more functional. Most bloating occurs in the abdomen and it comes from taking a big dose of creatine all at once, or if you're taking it alongside flow agents or fillers, they can cause gastrointestinal distress.
Or it can also be if you're adding it into a protein drink because amino acids also help pull water into different spaces. So protein and creatine are competing for the same amount of water, so you need to drink some more water. Here are some ways around this.
If you take a larger dose, split it into two or three doses of one and a half to two and a half grammes and make sure you're drinking enough water. The other claims, things like dehydration, cramping, kidney damage, have all been looked at repeatedly in world control studies and they haven't held up. Creatine is one of the most studied supplements in existence and it's generally well tolerated.
There are a few people that say they don't get on with it digestively, but for most people, if you build up slowly, they don't have a problem. If you have an existing kidney disease, then you need to have a conversation with your doctor. Mistake number three is that you quit before it works.
Creatine isn't caffeine. It doesn't work in 20 minutes. It works by gradually filling up the tank in your muscles and that tank takes around three to four weeks to fill.
Most women feel the difference in training and recovery somewhere between two and four weeks, but not usually on day one. The best time to take it is the time you'll actually take it. For me, that's in my morning coffee.
So I add creatine into my coffee and that stopped me thinking about when to fit it in. And yes, adding it into coffee is fine. It won't degrade it if you drink it within 30 minutes or so.
You can also add it into tea or green tea. Matcha is a little bit more difficult because matcha dissolves better in cold liquids while creatine dissolves better in warmer liquids. The important thing is to make it easy for you so that you take it every single day.
So let's talk about what it does when you're not training. This was a very interesting study. It showed that on the days women trained, the ones taking creatine slept almost 50 minutes longer.
Seven hours, 24 minutes against six hours, 36 minutes in the placebo group. This is what the study showed. For six weeks, women did resistance training twice a week, 35 to 45 minutes a session, and they took either five grammes of creatine daily or a placebo.
They tracked their sleep with aura rings. Overall sleep quality didn't change much. Both groups started and finished reporting poor sleep and their total sleep time was about the same.
The difference only showed up when the researchers separated training days from rest days. On rest days there was no difference at all so the creatine didn't magically improve their sleep. What it appears to do is to buffer the stress of training so a hard session doesn't end up costing you your night.
Why would that happen? Your body makes about half of the creatine it needs every day and making it costs you energy. So think of it like a household budget.
If your body is spending part of its income manufacturing creatine, that's money it can't spend on repairs. Supplementing takes that cost off the books and your body can redirect to what it saves. And there's also another detail I want to share.
Those women were only getting about a quarter to a third a gramme of creatine a day from food despite eating meat. They were probably running low before they started. What creatine does for your brain when you're sleep deprived is even more interesting.
Creatine seems to help most when your brain is under load, less so when you're rested and everything's fine. In a study in sleep-deprived adults, creatine improved cognitive performance after 36 hours without sleep. In another study, eight grammes a day for five days reduced mental fatigue in people doing demanding calculations.
In vegetarians who have lower baseline scores, five grammes a day for six weeks improved performance on a complex cognitive test. Do you see the pattern? If you're running a business or a team, raising children, sleeping badly and thinking hard all day, that's exactly the condition the research is pointing at.
This doesn't mean you should ignore your need for sleep and top up with creatine but it does mean that when you're travelling or sleep deprived, creatine can help make up for some of those deficits in brain energy. There's another part to the creatine story that often gets overstated and this is in relation to long-term brain health protection. There was a pilot study in 20 adults with early stage Alzheimer's disease.
They took 20 grammes a day for eight weeks. Their brain creatine stores increased by an average of 11 percent. Working memory improved by 17 percent and fluid cognition by 7 percent.
Those numbers are striking but that study had no control group and only 20 participants. It suggests that creatine does get into the brain and something moves in the right direction. It doesn't tell us creatine treats Alzheimer's.
If you're focused on longevity and maintaining your independence as you age, bone health is non-negotiable and this is where the research on creatine gets particularly interesting. A 2023 randomised control trial published in Medicine and Science in Sport and Exercise followed 237 post-menopausal women over two years. The women received either creatine at approximately 10 grammes a day for a 70 kilogramme woman or a placebo.
Both groups followed a programme of resistance training and walking. Now interestingly creatine didn't prevent the loss of bone mineral density at the hip, femoral neck or lumbar spine but here's what it did do. It improved certain measures of bone geometry at the hip including measures associated with the bone's ability to resist bending and that's an important distinction because bone density and bone structure aren't the same thing.
These changes could potentially help protect against fractures as we age although the study didn't establish that creatine actually reduces fracture risk. So while creatine hasn't been shown to prevent age-related bone density loss it may help preserve aspects of bone structure particularly when combined with resistance training. It's not a standalone solution but it could be another useful tool in supporting long-term bone health strength and independence.
So how much you actually take it depends on your goal. For muscle recovery and general use five grammes a day. For brain and daily cognitive support five to ten grammes.
For bone support after menopause alongside weight-bearing exercise eight to twelve grammes. If you're covering all three at once the research supports a floor of about five to ten grammes a day consistently and if you're heading into something short and intense like a brutal work week or a stretch of bad sleep there's research on 20 grammes a day for five to seven days. This is effective for short-term use for example if you're travelling across time zones.
To avoid any bloating it's best to split the dose across the day and if you're like most women I work with and you're currently taking nothing then start at one and a half to two and a half grammes and build up to five grammes and get really consistent for a month. Then decide whether you want to go higher. On the form of creatine to take creatine monohydrate is the most studied form.
Creatine HDL is showing promising research but it's still early days. Monohydrate is still the most studied, it's the cheapest and currently thought to be the most effective. For food sources for context red meat poultry and fish are good sources but an eight ounce day gives you roughly one gramme.
Milk has almost nothing and plants only have trace amounts so unless you're eating a lot of meat and fish you're probably not getting enough from food alone. So to close start low at one and a half to two and a half grammes per day and build up to five grammes every day for at least a month. Choose creatine monohydrate and drink plenty of water.
You don't have to be perfect to benefit you just have to be consistent and if you want the full breakdown including every study I mentioned today and more comment ultimate and I'll send you my free ultimate guide to creatine for women and if you want to know where your own biology is actually struggling the link in the description takes you to my free health assessment. It takes just two minutes and it will give you a free personalised score across five pillars and I'll tell you what to work on first. If you enjoyed this video please give it a like and share it with a friend you think should also start thinking about creatine.
Thank you so much for watching and I can't wait to see you in the next one.
DESCRIPTION
In this video, I explain the three mistakes that stop women over 40 getting the benefits of creatine, from taking a dose designed for young men to quitting before your muscles have had time to fill up. I also share the research on creatine for muscle, strength, sleep, brain energy and bone health after menopause, plus exactly how much to take for your goal and the easiest way to make it a daily habit.
VIDEO
VALUABLE RESOURCES
Click here for discounts on all the products I personally use and recommend
The Ultimate Guide to Creatine for Women -
👉 https://academy.angelafosterperformance.com/creatine-guide
VALUABLE RESOURCES
- Take the BioSyncing Quiz to help you understand what’s actually happening in your body — and how to fix it.
👉 https://biosyncing.scoreapp.com/
Want to go deeper? Start here:
Reset your hormones, restore your energy, and reconnect with your body in just 21 days.
👉 https://www.highperformance-health.com
▶️ Watch Next:
Continue learning with these empowering conversations:
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon on Women's Metabolism, Muscle and Midlife Health
https://youtu.be/HrLPMkNMeY4?si=yKKVNwBVjGQYvGr1
Dr. Darren Candow on Creatine, Muscles and Bone Health
https://youtu.be/sLWaRcKNjMo?si=W7c4THElXiI7BC9G
Disclaimer: The High Performance Health Podcast is for general information purposes only and do not constitute the practice of professional or coaching advice and no client relationship is formed. The use of information on this podcast, or materials linked from this podcast is at the user's own risk. The content of this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for medical or other professional advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Users should seek the assistance of their medical doctor or other health care professional for before taking any steps to implement any of the items discussed in this podcast.
Recent Episodes
About Angela
Angela Foster is an award winning Nutritionist, Health & Performance Coach, Keynote Speaker and Host of The High Performance Health Podcast.
A former corporate lawyer turned industry leader in biohacking and health optimisation for women, Angela regularly gives keynotes to large fitness, health and wellness events including the Health Optimisation summit, The Biohacker summit, Dragonfly live, Elevate Fitness conference and Gaia TV. She also delivers Health Optimisation and Performance Workshops to large multinational corporations and senior leaders with a strong focus on women’s health and burnout prevention.
Angela is also the creator of BioSyncing® a blueprint for high performing women who want to ditch burnout, harmonise their hormones and elevate their life.





